Friday, October 29, 2010

And the responses...

"Pretty fair observations. I hope your experience was enriching. I wish you could have spent time with me and my family, but on to the next one. what's next? Mormonism?
There is only so much which can be experienced from without. that's true of anything. I could tell that you drew these conclusions from what you observed. You tried to be fair. they only saw what they wanted to see. they fixated on the "negative" and ignored the fact that you said the same could be true of Christians. Offense is a choice we all too often make.


Well, Joni, I applaud your courage. Many of the women surely thought that by the end of your experiment you would become Muslim and so they were "pimping" Islam to you, but when you didn't they showed their true intentions by insulting and summarily dismissed you. I had the same issues the others did, but I realize that you cannot report anything other than what you observe. I love my brothers and sisters in Islam, but many time I have been completely pissed at some of the unpatriotic things I've heard from them. I hope you continue to meet Muslims and learn from them. We come in all shape and sizes and we are all things at different times."
--J
~ * ~ * ~ * ~ * ~

"Joni.. I honestly, do not feel that you have captured the essence of Islam the way that it is practiced by the majority. I am not certain where you have gotten much of your "numbers" from but I can assure you that a lot of Muslims I know *are* patriotic. A lot of Sisters I know have jobs out side of the home that their husbands support 100%.


I will be the first to stand here and say that my husband supports my decision in being a Doula and Insha'Allah (If Allah Wills), a Midwife. He knows the bumpy road that Midwives and their families endure and he is ready to travel along with me. Alhamdulilah for the man that I married who is not only culturally rich but also Islamically pure AND patriotic to the country in which he IS a citizen of (USA). If it was not FOR HIM, I would not be who I am today. I would not be able to give my time to every cause that I possibly want to. I would not be able to even aspire to what I want to be in life.


In addition, we as Muslim women SHOULD be mindful of our families. It IS a duty to our Creator to manage all of what Allah has given us and if we can do that, juggle school AND a career then there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with that. I am sure other sisters would agree. And I assure you, there are plenty of us who have the same "family system".


Many of the Muslims I know left their countries to come HERE... they ARE patriotic, more patriotic than a lot of Americans that I know. Goodness, my husband knows more about government and politics than I do as he takes a keen interest in learning about it. He knows more than what we have been taught in school and I think it is great that he does.


There is only thing that Muslims do not forget. It is where they came from and WHO they are returning TO... That is the way we must live our lives. We shouldn't spend our life to adhere to every desire that we have but we should adhere our lives in pleasing the Creator.


I wanted to add one more thing... well, maybe.. My husband is not only supportive of me being a Midwife but he has encouraged me (and paid every cent and watched the kiddos for me) to get my Associates in Early Childhood Teaching. I am complete in my studies except for the work portion in which he is TAKING OFF from work for me to complete so that the children are well taken care of. I cannot give him enough credit for where I am in life.


Thank you for the clarification for the numbers. I know some women in both scenarios but I guess I Just know more women in the same scenario as myself. Allah Knows Best.


It's not about defending *myself* but it is about defending ...the religion of which I belong to. Islam itself allows women to work and make her OWN money. not a single CENT of that money belongs to the husband or family and IF the woman decides to use the money for her family, it is CHARITY! This is the beauty of us working. Suban'Allah! Islam covers all aspects of our lives and men who are truly adhering to Allah's Law.. they are the ones whose wives would be utmost pleased.


May Allah Guide in all that you do and I pray you understand that whatever good I have said is from Allah and whatever wrong I have said is from myself."
--A

~ * ~ * ~ * ~ * ~

"Sorry but when you stated, "My concern was the lack of ambition and goals outside of family that many Muslim women have," that is a bunch of BS! Sorry but it is! I am finishing my degree, R is working on hers, A is working on becoming a mid-wife, L is working on her PhD, and there are many Muslim women working outside of the home. However, yes there are Muslim men who do not help with housework or the children but there are many christian men who do not help either. I am not sure where you went to get your biased information but I have found many of your blogs offensive and disheartening towards Muslims, with biased opinions or repeated thoughts of prejudices of someone who has not really spent time with Muslims. Sorry was not impressed cause I could have read the same information on the fox news site. Good luck on your next religion; however, I feel diving into your religion would better for you. You may be shocked to find out things you didn't know about your own religion! That would be a blog I would be interested in! ;)"
--S


Feel free to add additional comments below... :-) 

Day 32 - Whoa! Time Out!!

Wow, I got alot of backlash from that last post, so let me pleeeeease clarify some things that I said:

The part where I said [End Objectivism, Begin Opinion] meant that I was beginning my opinion - my PERCEPTION, my experience of Islam. I am trying to experience the religions (not just Islam, however, Islam is my first in this experiment). The other religions will recieve the same scrutiny but also the same positivity that I gave Islam. I wanted to present a true picture not only of the religion, but also of MY EXPERIENCE within the religion.

Thirty Days is not enough time to do that, so I missed a million things. I will miss a million things on every religion. Hang in there, these are just hors d'oeuvres. You need to check them out for yourself for the full meal!

That said, in my last post, I pointed out some things that I didn't think too highly of. But there were many parts of Islam that I really loved:

:: I think the prayer five times a day speaks to dedication and honoring God. I did not meet a single Muslim woman who did not do the prayer five times a day. They didn't do this at gunpoint, it was their choice.

:: I think the Muslim family values, the importance placed on family, while it might be overly beneficial for fathers (who I believe in this day and age should share equally in parenting responsibilities), is something American society could use an injection of.

I don't have a problem with Moms who choose to stay home and choose to go down the path of being a mother and making that their career. And I think that American society today undermines the choices of stay at home moms and devalues them as a whole, labeling them "women without a choice", or women "giving up" everything for their families.

That said, I don't believe that being a stay-at-home mom is the first choice for all women (myself included), and I think some women are pressured to do EVERYTHING. I believe that mothers and fathers should have equal responsibility in the whole raising-a-child thing. If the mother has dreams and goals outside the home, why is she less worthy of going after those than a father, simply because she doesnt have a penis?

Obviously there were exceptions (as I pointed out). "Many" does not mean "All". I would say, in my case, that I am the EXCEPTION for Christians, and maybe I am wrong, but I think most Christians would not delve into other religions and discover what they believe and what is beautiful about their religions. At least most Christians I know. And don't think this has been a cake walk on my end, either. My family was, for the most part, horrified when I told them of the experiment. My boss would not allow me to take part in the experiment while I was at work, and wanted to know nothing about Muslims. Some friends deleted me on facebook, some friends sent me lengthy emails about opening spiritual doors and making myself vulnerable to satan. I am not lying.

:: Muslim views on women being able to have an abortion, at least in theory, and their views on the importance of a woman in Islam spoke very highly among its peer religions. While I am not pro-abortion, I AM pro-choice, and I think that people SHOULD have a choice about what happens to their bodies. There are lines I draw, sure, and I certainly don't like abortion or agree with it under all circumstances, but hats off to Islam for giving women permission to not raise a child they didn't want (especially in situations like rape or incest)!

:: Lastly, regarding Patriotism, as way of explanation: I am from a military family. I UNDERSTAND that not everyone feels the same way about America that I do, and that is ok. I'm not going to tell you that if you don't put your hand over your heart and pledge allegiance to the flag that you should pack your things and leave this country. But I will say that I raise my children to love this country, respect the freedom that we have (ESPECIALLY religious freedom) and to understand that if they can try to walk in other people's shoes and live with compassion, they will make this country a better place to live.


In conclusion, this blog is as much for my children as it is for myself. It is about showing my children that people are similar, even if their beliefs are different. It is to educate my children when they grow older, in whatever way I can, to the cultures and beliefs of other people. It is to teach them to love. And it is, in some way, to teach them to think and make decisions on their own, and use thier minds to compare and contrast.

In truth, almost everything I write is truly for my children. I want them to understand a different perspective is not always a wrong perspective. I want them to believe in the power to dream. I want them to have permission to become whatever they desire - spiritually, religiously, politically, educationally and career-wise. And if something happens to me and I don't get to be part of their lives in the future(God forbid), I want them to know who I am and how I thought. Call it ego, call it legacy - I want to leave something for my children and grandchildren to see, and more than that, I want my voice to be heard. I want my children to grow up with the belief that people should be judged individually based on their character and actions, rather than stereotyped. I want them to change this world for the better and live a life of open curiousity and radical compassion. I want them to not be AFRAID to try something new just because it is unfamiliar.

I hope I didn't offend too many Muslims during this 30 days... I understand people are passionate about their religion, and I never meant to be disrespectful. The women I met were nothing but hospitable and loving toward me and I respect and admire them all greatly - both the Fort Worthers and the Dallas-ites. I welcome any and all feed back!

My next post will be some of the responses I got on my 30th day as a Muslim.

Day 30 - Uncovering (and) [Insert Opinion Here]

I apologize for not having blogged this week, I have been sick and sleeping during all of my free time, so blogging took a back burner.

Day 30 came and went on Wednesday, and found me going to the grocery store for Halloween candy and cold medicine. I wore one of Mark's short-sleeved t-shirt over yoga pants.

I have to say, when I went to the grocery store uncovered not only was I FREEZING, I felt almost naked without my protective wrap of scarf and shirt!! Much like when I first started wearing hijab, I felt that people were looking at me in my "nakedness"!!

I also realized that taking off my hijab caused another issue that was unexpected. The hijab is almost a barrier between myself and being judged. Stay with me here. When I wear hijab, I am telling people right at the get-go that I am Muslim. There is a very slim chance that they will judge me later - either they want to be nice to me as a Muslim, or they don't. I'm putting it out there and by putting it all out there, risking less chance of rejection later on - at least on the religious choices spectrum. It is, in that way, a wall between myself and the outside world, and if people are willing to still talk to me, be friends with me, reach out to me, I know up front that they are ok with the fact that I am a Muslim. Unlike when they find out after talking to me that I am, in fact, NOT a super-Christian, or that I AM a Christian, or a Mormon, etc.

Being a Muslim did not particularly change my life all that much. Not eating pork was a little challenging, given my love of pizza, but it was do-able. Following the rules of washing and praying was an adjustment, but after getting used to it, was easy. The pre-dawn prayers were the hardest for me, and the lunch time prayers, while I thought they would be difficult, being how I was at work during that time, were easier.

I learned a number of things about the religion that I shared with you... and here are my thoughts: [End Objectivism, Begin Opinion]

1. The women I met are modern women with rights and lives outside of their homes. In theory. The fact that they CHOOSE to be submissive to their husbands, go home immediately in the middle of a girls' night because their husband refuses to change a baby diaper, reschedule meetings because their husbands' meetings trump theirs, can't follow a career path because their husband doesn't want to be bothered with picking up the slack for a working wife... those things separate them from what a non-religious modern woman might deal with. However, those are things that, regardless of how far women have come, many MANY women deal with, regardless of how "liberated" we technically are. My concern was the lack of ambition and goals outside of family that many Muslim women have. I understand the importance of family, but I also understand the importance of fulfillment. Sometimes (not all the time), in my experience, just reproducing and raising children and being married, cooking dinners, cleaning house does not a fulfilled woman make.

2. I was stunned by the number of Muslim people who don't value America in the same way I do. I was stunned that 1 out of 4 AMERICAN Muslim young men between 18 and 30 said they didn't condemn the terrorist attacks on 9/11. I was stunned to find that statistic true in both the articles I read and the people I met - who may not agree with the taking of innocent lives, but justified the reason those lives were taken. I was stunned that American Muslims are not American first. I had to examine myself and find out - was I a Christian first or an American first, particularly when I was actively involved in Christian life? I came to the conclusion that I was American first. "God AND Country" was how I was brought up, God having almost equal footing with America. America representing the ideals of how I could live my life and how far my potential could reach, and God being the boundary to guide my character. While there might have been a time once when I thought, as the Christian right does, that this country was (is) a Christian country founded on Christian ideals, I would never have supported the idea of removing all religious freedom except that of the Christian. I find that many American Muslims would do just that, making this an Islamic nation, and, like the Christian right, reducing or eliminating the rights of others to choose another religion.

When you take a group of people from countries that hate America, and have been trained all their life to hate America (for valid reasons, in many cases), then you transplant them as adults or young adults to American soil for education and opportunity, it is no surprise that they continue to see the viewpoint of countries who hate America. I'm not saying it is their fault, I'm simply saying that it was surprising to me.

3. Another surprise for me was how politically and culturally entrenched the religion is as a whole. Many of the rituals practiced are cultural hand-me-downs, continued to be practiced in a culture where they are no longer as relevant. It was difficult to separate the religion from the culture in which it was formed. I had expected, going in, that the religion was practiced in its pure form - unlike, I thought, the diluted and Americanized form of Christianity we practice here. Not so. Islam has the same difficulties with cultural influence that we have in Christian churches, the only difference is that theirs is a convergence of two opposing cultures influencing the religion.

More reflections (read: opinions) to come... :-)

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Day 29 - Obsession with Purpose

OBSESSED
I have this obsession. It has always been with my "purpose in life," meaning my "calling" (can we say narcissistic?). I am constantly reevaluating what I should do with my life. Where most people leave the "what do I want to be when I grow up?" question behind them when they graduate college, I have been on an eternal quest to find my career path.

I believe that everyone was put on this earth with a purpose - an end in mind. There are secondary things as well, that we are purposed to do, and that come as companions to our purpose, walking with us through different phases of our lives. For instance, I believe it is my purpose to communicate with people in a way that they can understand through the medium of writing. I am passionate about unifying people, changing my world, helping to expand hearts and minds through education and perspective, helping people find love for each other. Maybe I will help one or two people in my lifetime see things differently and love more freely, and if that happens, I will have accomplished my purpose. But as I work to accomplish my purpose, there are companions to my purpose: Being a mother, for instance. I have not always been a mother, and someday, I will not be involved with raising children on a daily basis. But in being a mother, I can teach my children to love and communicate, and to not judge their fellow humans - in this way, I am accomplishing what I was made to do. I am not saying that being a mother is not the greatest calling, but I am saying that for most people, it is not the ONLY calling, and, again, for most people, believing that it IS the only purpose of their life will lead to nothing but frustration and despondency. Because being a Mother is a choice, it cannot be your primary purpose, only a role that you play during your life (albeit an important one).



Who are you? No, really. Who ARE you?
Your purpose goes beyond your career, beyond your education and vocation. It is intrinsically WHO YOU ARE. It is not what you were made to DO, it is who you were made to be. My purpose is to educate and write and communicate. My purpose is NOT to run a non-profit, or to speak to masses of people, or to be the best darn HR Director that Sonic has ever seen, although those can all be choices I make. It is not to perform delicate brain surgery, or track down criminals in foreign countries, or to paint murals on overpasses. My purpose is to communicate through writing, and because a writer is who I AM, actually, I find it hard to reconcile that as a reasonable or respectable occupation. For the simple fact that I need measurable success in order to feel successful. I need a promotion, I need a list of lives that have been saved, I need something tangible that says I have succeeded. Ah, but this is the fallacy of finding our purpose and allowing our lives to be driven by that purpose: we can do whatever we want to, make whatever choice we want in life, and pursue whatever career we desire, but unless we recognize what we were made for, we will live a life of constant frustration.

Some people claim that they don't know their purpose, but I would postulate that their purpose is not unknown to them as much as it is unaccepted by them. They want their purpose to be something recognizable and accomplishable. They want to have a set path. They want their purpose to be their career. And for a lucky few, that is the case. The rest of us are called to trying to accomplish our purpose in whatever place we are.

I am a writer and explorer (even though it may not appear from this blog that I am a very GOOD writer). I am not a writer because I "write good" though, I'm a writer because my purpose is to help people understand other's perspectives - it is in my nature. I can communicate in a way some can't, I'm not afraid to jump into the unknown, and I can relate to people in the written word. But "writer" has never been enough for me (or maybe it has always been too much for me). I feel like I should build something, or do something meaningful, and so I have searched my entire life to find my "purpose" because my purpose wasn't good enough for me - I wanted my purpose to be a career.

I would further postulate that when people begin to embrace their purpose, they find that their lives are much more and much less satisfactory. They are more satisfied because they finally are DOING what they are made to do. Throwing caution to the wind, abandoning yourself into your purpose, you walk out there on that ledge and discover that this is what you were MADE for!
...But the flip side is that once you embrace your purpose, you are forever ruined for the rest of the things in this world. Not to say that you can't be happy doing several things at once, but if you abandon your purpose in search of something "better" or "more appropriate" or "more meaningful" you will always be disappointed.

Abandoning who I am and who I was made to be - the elemental parts of myself that have nothing to do with personal choice - would be setting me up for failure. I must give myself permission to be who I am.

Expectations
Too many time women in particular have been given their purpose and their destiny by someone playing God. They have been told that they must grow up and go to business school and climb the corporate ladder. Or (more often) they must marry and have children and their purpose is to be a good wife and mother. They are not given permission to dream.

Too many times in American society, women create a checklist of expectations. Mostly self-imposed, yes, but trying to live up to society’s expectations of getting degrees, climbing the corporate ladder, doing something meaningful in our community, and at the same time, balancing a child on each hip and singlehandedly keeping our families strong and healthy. As a woman, we have all walked into the world and have achieved some level of success, in some area of our lives. But, that checklist we created? Didn’t have to do with OUR dreams and desires, it had to do with what the people around us expected, and with what society in general expected.

For myself, I was balancing a corporate career, being single mom to three great kids, and completing my degree. I felt that in my effort to succeed in every area of my life, I was inadvertently failing at each one. There finally came a point when I said, “What am I doing with my life? I’m not happy! To heck with the checklist, I’m going to dream!” Almost immediately the question arose: “What DO I want? What ARE my dreams?” And when I gave myself permission to ask those questions – and ANSWER them – I began to, at last, feel that I had begun to succeed.

I am here today giving YOU permission to dream. I am giving you permission to examine your purpose outside of the light of the church, the religion you were brought up in, the family you are a part of, the career path you have chosen. I give you permission to ask the question - WHAT IS MY PURPOSE? But you must give yourself permission to hear the answer.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Day 28 - The Quran

As you probably realize by now, the Quran is the Muslim "bible"... and beyond that, it guides them on prettymuch every aspect of life. It is the dictionary to a Scrabble game - consulted on almost every issue that comes up in a Muslim life.

According to the Quran, it is "the Book in which there is no doubt, in it is guidance for those who fear God, who believe in the unseen...and who believe in that which was sent down to you [Muhammad], and that which was sent down before you (the Books and the prophets - ie, the old Testament) and have certain faith in the hereafter. The are on (true) guidance from their Lord, and it is these who will prosper." Quran 2:2-5

Whew. I think in that glowing accolade, the Quran was basically just swearing that it is the Truth, the Whole Truth, and nothing BUT the Truth! That said, it probably is a tiny bit biased on its accuracy. Considering that it is claiming to be the truth, and that claim not by an objective third party. I'm just saying.

So what evidence supports the Quran's claim of authenticity? Supposedly, it is the only "revealed book" that exists today in the precise form and content in which it was originally revealed.
Even if the Quran has been preserved, what evidence supports that it is the Word of God and not simply Muhammad's(pbuh) own writings?

How can you be sure that parts haven't been lost or "misplaced"?

Apparently, during Muhammad's lifetime, the book was written down AND memorized as it was revealed. The written portion was checked against the memorized portion and vice-versa. Interestingly, it is one of the only books that has been memorized in its entirity by millions of people!

Nonetheless, we are taking the word of Muhammad and his group of disciples/followers that this is exactly what God said, much like the Bible, so an element of faith is inherent in the belief that this is the infallible Word of God.

In my mind, you cannot prove a fact with evidence from the same source - it comes down to the parental answer to the question "why?" - "Because I said so." Oh really? Because you said? Well, then that makes it fact, right?

So, faith in hand, Muslims believe as fact that the Quran is the speech of God written by Muhammad. If you take this as a given, then the question remains whether it is still in its original form. Historically, the Arabic society has excelled at story-telling and has a strong oral tradition, so the idea that the Quran could have been memorized and passed along verbatim is not SO far-fetched. Additionally, one must keep in mind that the Quran was written in 600 AD, and while that was not the present age of document preservation and provable evidence, it was nonetheless written in a relatively MORE modern time than other documents, such as the Old Testament and New Testament. It was written over 500 years after the New Testament was complete, and over 100 years after the entire Bible had been translated into 500 languages. Given the relative technology and records that the world had at that time, it is definitely believable that this book could have been kept in its original form, especially considering that it had but one author, who wrote the entire thing during his lifetime. Additionally, it was written in the same primary language of the religion, unlike other books (the Bible).

Outside of that, the Quran does seem to have knowledge of scientific things that were only discovered years later, which bolsters its claim to being a prophetic book - for instance, the Quran described the planet earth as a sphere and egg-shaped ("like and ostrich egg" Quran 79:30). This claim wasn't proven scientifically for another 900 years or so.
The Quran describes the development of a fetus in rough but accurate terms as well in surah 23:12-14.

So I guess you'd have to say, unless you were alive in 600 AD when the Quran was being written, that you will have to take a measure of it's historical accuracy and literary preservation on faith. And, truly, you would need to take the accuracy of other such religious texts on faith in like fashion.

But I think even without the 100% knowledge that what is written is exactly as it was 600 years ago, most Muslims would tell you that they abide by the principles therein because of their independent value - they do what the book says not only because they believe it to be the word of God, but because it just makes sense to them. So there you have it.

Note, as a reader commented, although the words of the Quran were spoken by Muhammad and thereafter written down, he was not the one with pen in hand writing these words, he only spoke what he felt Allah said to him. Scribes and/or followers copied down the words.

Friday, October 22, 2010

Day 25 - Parenting

For a religion that tells you which side of your body to wash first in the bathtub, is it any wonder that Islam has quite a number of instructions regarding parenting as well? As I was learning the information regarding parenting in Islam, I found that there was one thing that surprised me (the stance on breastfeeding), as well as a few things that are just good practices for ANYONE, regardless of their religion!

Breastfeeding: It was interesting to me to see that the Quran specifically addresses breastfeeding! Not just to DO it, but the length of time that is recommended, what to do if the mother cannot (or will not) breastfeed, and what happens in the case of a divorce...

“The mothers shall give suck to their offspring for two whole years, if the father desires to complete the term. But he shall bear the cost of their food and clothing on equitable terms if they both decide on weaning, by mutual consent, and after due consultation, there is no blame on them. If ye decide on a foster-mother for your offspring there is no blame on you, provided ye pay (her) what ye offered, on equitable terms. But fear Allah and know that Allah sees well what ye do.” (2:233)

Parents and Children:
"Rights" of various people are emphasized frequently in the Quran, probably due to the Arabic society from which Islam originated which disregarded almost every right of anyone except an Arabic Male.

The mothers in particular have an important role in child-rearing (since that is their major obligation) much more so than the father, who is ordered to provide for the family and go out to work and to war. Islam reinforces the family as the most basic social unit. It encourages children to thank their parents, most particularly the Mother, who has had to be pregnant with the child, delivery, sacrifice, breastfeeding, and care/nurture for the child. It's an interesting side note that Muhammad (pbuh) himself was an orphan and probably had some elevated ideas about how it would be to have parents and how he would treat them if he did. In addition to saying in short that a mother should be cared for and loved at least three times more than a father, Muhammad (pbuh) goes a step further to say that doing good and caring for your mother will result in points for your good bucket. "Paradise lies under the feet of the mother."


RIGHTS OF PARENTS:
(1) To be respected and obeyed [by their children]. This one made me laugh a little bit - you can give me a badge and a gun with that unconditional respect and obedience, and I doubt my children will still respect that RIGHT of mine 100% of the time!! The Prophet (pbuh) further mentions that if a child "annoys" or "disobeys" their parent, it can and will lead to God's wrath. Perhaps this would be a bigger motivator?
(2) To discipline and guide in order to protect the child and mold them into a fine upstanding citizen and Muslim. (The Quran even says spanking is A-Okay)
(3) To be looked after, should they become ill, old, or otherwise unable to look after themselves, financially in particular.
::“People ask you (O Prophet) how should they spend. Say, ‘whatever you spend should be spent on Allah (in good cause), on parents, near relatives, on orphans, destitutes and travelers (who fall short of money in foreign lands).”::
(4) To be helped physically (with cleaning, lifting, or any manner of things they need help with).
(5) To be spoken to and behaved toward kindly. Including NOT putting them into nursing homes, being kind and respectful (no matter how crazy and old they are).


RIGHTS OF CHILDREN:
(1) Food, clothes, protection (both physical and moral)
(2) Education - religious and bookish knowledge is required. The goal - to develop a well-rounded personality. The Prophet (pbuh) believed in education for ALL children, both girls and boys, and said once "The best of you is one who gives a good education to his children."
(3) Love and Affection - The Prophet (pbuh) emphasized the importance of love and affection for children. He was himself orphaned and assumedly devoid of that love and affection throughout his own childhood, so he sought to enforce upon the people around him the importance of love and affection of children. He even adopted an orphaned child and treated him as a son his whole life. Stories have it that the Prophet (pbuh) loved children greatly: He would allow his grandsons Hassan and Hussain to ride his shoulders even during his prayers. In streets he would offer ‘salaam’ to children, play and cut jokes with them. Sometimes he would even kiss small children in the street. Once a Bedouin saw the Prophet kissing a small kid. Out of wonder he said, “I have eight children but I never kiss them”. The Prophet remarked, “What can I do if Allah has taken away love and compassion from your heart”. The Prophet would show special kindness to orphaned children.
(4) To be well provided for financially - it was emphasized that parents should be concerned with what they are leaving behind for their children - not spending their money on themselves and their material possessions, but laying up stores to provide for their children

These are great principles for anyone to follow, regardless of whether they are Muslim or not!

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Day 24 - Sex, Contraception and Abortion

Much as with other religions, sex outside of marriage (in certain circumstances) or before marriage is unlawful. However, sex within marriage is explicitly encouraged!

The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, “You merit rewards of charity in your sexual union with your spouses!” His companions asked in surprise, “How shall we getting rewards for fulfilling our natural instincts?” He asked, “What if someone were to fulfill his desire unlawfully; would he/she be punished for doing so?” They replied, “Certainly.” Then he said, “Likewise, when one does it within the framework of marriage, he/she will be rewarded for it!”


Not only is it permissable to have sex within your marriage, it is rewardable - points in your "good bucket" (see Day 16 regarding Judgment Day and good/bad buckets).
Now coming to the issue of contraception: there is nothing in Islam that prohibits it so long as it is done consensually for valid reasons such as the following: putting off pregnancy until such time when the spouses are in a better position to shoulder the responsibilities of parenting, to allow for space between pregnancies in order to provide proper nurturing and care to existing children, etc. Bottom line: No Qur'anic text forbids prevention of conception.

BUT, contraception does not amount to killing a human being. The pre-Islamic Arab practice of killing or burying alive a newborn child (particularly a girl) on account of the parents' poverty or to refrain from having a female child is expressly forbidden in the Quran.

In the Hadith (a collection of "gospels" of the Quran, not written by Muhammad), the principle of preventing conception via coitus interruptus was approved via the Prophet (pbuh). Some examples are:
:: According to Jabir, "We used to practise coitus interruptus during the Prophet's (pbuh) lifetime. News of this reached him and he did not forbid us." then later "A man came to the Prophet (pbuh) and said, 'I have a slave girl, and we need her as a servant and around the palmgroves. I have sex with her, but I am afraid of her becoming pregnant.' The Prophet (pbuh) said, 'Practice 'azl with her if you so wish, for she will receive what has been predestined for her.'"

:: According to Abu Sa'id, "We rode out with the Prophet (pbuh) to raid Banu al-Mustaliq and captured some female prisoners . . . we desired women and abstinence became hard. [But] we wanted to practise 'azl; and asked the Prophet (pbuh) about it. He said, 'You do not have to hesitate, for God has predestined what is to be created until the judgement day.'"

:: According to 'Umar Ibn Khattab, "The Prophet (pbuh) forbade the practice of 'azl with a free woman except with her permission."

So there seems to be permission for a man to exercise contraceptive moves whenever he pleases, except unless a free woman denies him the priviledge...
NOTE: There are a few reasons why a "free woman" he is married to can be vetoed: (1) a desire to preserve a woman's beauty or her health, or save her life; (2) desire to avoid financial hardship and embarrassment; (3) avoidance of other domestic problems caused by a large family. He did not accept avoidance of female birth as a legitimate motive for contraception. (4)If the child will grow up (the husband fears) in a morally unhealthy environment. All according to the Muslim Jurists - the Hanbali and Maliki groups, Zydiyah scholars, and the first three specific to Al-Ghazzali scholars)

Double Standards... I am certain that you, Dear Readers, did not miss the implied consent in earlier examples. The implied consent is both that contraception is ok, and it is apparently ok for men to have sex with a variety of women who are not their wives, as long as it in convenient, or if they really really need it. I have never found any example of a time when it is permissable for a woman to have sex with someone other than their husband, however...

Maybe its just too difficult for men to only have sex with their wives or abstain altogether? "We desired women and abstinence became hard." Well, by all means, if it's hard, give it up! Seriously, though, the double standard is apparent in the sex rules.

Abortion
Islam expressly prohibits killing a child after it has been born.
"Don’t kill your children [immediately after birth]... verily killing them is a most heinous crime!” (Al-Isra’: 31)

However, the Abortion topic has been debated in Muslim circles. All of the scholars seem to agree that no infant should be killed after the soul has entered the body. HOWEVER, when has the soul entered the body? At conception? 40 days after conception? 120 days after conception? The scholars have debated this, and a lot of them believe that the fetus changes into a human on the magical 120th day after conception, and therefore abortion (for good reason) before this is acceptable. Almost certainly the morning-after pill is widely acceptable, and later term abortions seem to be debatable... probably very dependent on the geographical area (and the availabilty and social view of abortions.


Overall, these views are really opposed to the Jewish and most Christian views on contraception, sex, and abortion! Its one of the biggest differences I've seen between Islam and other major world religions.

POST SCRIPT -
Since I know alot of people don't read through the comments, it is really interesting to see that the Quran DOES address foreplay and the Prophet forbade intercourse without foreplay!

ALSO, it is interesting to note that the Quran says you should breastfeed for two years! Yay for Islamic breastfeeders!! :-)

Read the comments!